Skip to main content

Currency shortages: The only thing we learn from Zimbabwe`s history is that Zimbabwe learns nothing from its history.





“The only thing we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history.” Perhaps nowhere else in the world is this statement by Friedrech Hegel more apt today than Zimbabwe, where judging by current events, not only has the proverbial wheel fallen off, but so too has the axle and the suspension. “It`s is 2008 all over again,” is the common catchphrase of late, what with, winding queues for fuel becoming common, a pyrrhic bull-run on the Zimbabwe Stock Exchange fueled by absolutely nothing but fear and uncertainty, and an unhinged parallel market for foreign currency among other things.

Heck, phrases such as “profiteering”; “illegal price-hikes;” and “unscrupulous retailers” are becoming trendy again with the state-owned media. Zimbabwe has been here before, and with the memories of the dark hyper-inflationary period still fresh in the minds of many, it seems Zimbabwe has repeated past mistakes, and is staring down the barrel.

Before the much storied 2008 meltdown however, there was the early 2000s crisis. Below are just three examples showing the likely scenarios to play out in the economy, if what we have seen in the past is anything to go by. And no, I am no prophet!

Exchange Controls

Back in the day, as Zimbabwe`s foreign currency reserves petered away, the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe (RBZ) issued a directive essentially compelling most exporters to sell 25% of their export proceeds to the central bank, which the RBZ would then channel toward imports of fuel, electricity and various other select priority imports. In fact, by the end of September 2000, external payment arrears had reached about US$500 million, similar to the $600 million current backlog. This 25% “surrender requirement” was subsequently moved upwards to 40%, then 50% as the foreign currency crisis deteriorated.

Exporters could only access the balance under the confines of the priority list and obviously subject to RBZ approval. Of course this only accelerated the rate of the increase in the parallel market premiums charged for the US Dollar, which at the time hovered around 2,900% according to some estimates. Currently, with the mining sector for instance, 50% of all export proceeds are transferred into the RBZ`s Nostro account and the RBZ transfers the equivalent to a banks` RTGS account for the account of the exporter. This has been going in since May 2016, showing that history does indeed repeat itself.

Price Controls





“President to act on illegal price hikes,” screamed the headline in the state-owned, Herald Newspaper, quoting President Mugabe`s speech a day after his return from the United Nations General Assembly in New York. To the discerning observer, this can only mean price controls are well and truly upon us. Forget how time and time again, this strategy has proven to be futile. You can bet your bottom dollar that the suits in government will pursue this course of action. In October 2001, Zimbabwe`s government introduced price controls on basic commodities particularly key staples after unrelenting attacks on retailers and manufacturers, who were accused by government of “profiteering.” 

Effectively, the wholesale and retail prices of basic commodities and foods came under government control, resulting in immediate shortages of these commodities. Controlled prices were often way below the cost of production, something which would only serve to prop up the parallel market where these commodities were available at a price reflecting the actual production cost. This would go on until 2003, when faced with the ineffectiveness of its price control policy, government introduced a Prices and Incomes Stabilisation Protocol where negotiation of prices of crucial commodities and services such as mealie-meal, cooking oil, sugar, bread, rentals and rates, and transport fares would occur under a Tripartite Negotiation Forum. Shortages and further price increases have never been effectively dealt with using price controls, and this was to be the case in this instance.

Inflation

Officially, the latest statistics released by Zimstat say inflation is 0.14%. However, given what is happening on the local stock market, the parallel market premiums and general common sense, this 0.14% assertion is manifestly untrue. To get a more realistic picture of the inflation trends in Zimbabwe presently, one needs to look no further than the parallel exchange rate movements often used as a proxy for inflation. Like what we have become accustomed to, as the inflation rate inevitably gets out of hand in the coming months, the private sector will be chastised for its “profiteering” and “unscrupulous” practices, even in spite of the loose monetary policies we have witnessed from the RBZ.

In the 2000s, as soon as the prices began to rise, virtually no one wanted to retain cash, and everyone tried to get rid of it through investing in real estate or equity or any other physical asset, bricks included. The prices for assets such as these started to inflate, fueled on one hand by relatively low interest rates paid on money market papers in comparison to the increase of price levels, resulting in a de-facto negative interest rate. Manufacturers and producers are principal beneficiaries of the collapse of a currency: wage rates rarely keep up with the rate of inflation, taxes are eroded, the real value of mortgage debts are rapidly reduced.

In the immediate term, we will continue to see the flight from electronic currency into physical assets as people seek to preserve value. Again, history has shown that inflationary conditions such as witnessed during Zimbabwe`s hyperinflation period create opportunities for rent-seeking individuals profiting from such crises to seek to lengthen such crises for their benefit, and this will likely be the case in Zimbabwe too.

Data obtained from the IMF Staff Reports for 2000, 2001 and 2003

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Black Friday 1997: How the Zimbabwe dollar crashed and tipped the economy over the brink

14 November 1997 – dubbed “Black Friday”-  is a day that will forever be etched in Zimbabwe`s economic history as the cataclysmic point that triggered Zimbabwe`s economic free-fall. Below is a brief chronicle of the events leading up to this seminal day, and what ensued in the aftermaths of Black Friday. In the second decade of its independence, the Zimbabwean government launched an economic reform programme essential in liberalizing the economy and dealing with the structural impediments to growth. However, fiscal policy was weak and monetary policy unsteady during the time period; and the country suffered from two serious droughts (in 1992 and 1995), which affected Zimbabwe’s agriculture, its primary economic industry. A land reform had been a highly contentious issue since independence, as the majority of prime agricultural land was owned by about 4,000 white commercial farmers; while the indigenous population continued to engage in subsistence farming. In the first five years

The story behind the iconic Meikles Hotel and its founder Thomas Meikle

Old Meikles Hotel Buidling 1924: Credit - Meikles Hotel Twitter Feed The 15 th of November marks the 102 nd anniversary of Meikles hotel, a hotel founded by Thomas Meikle, following on a vision he shared with his brother Stewart, of establishing a hotel on the influential site overlooking Cecil Square (now called Africa Unity Square, in the heart of then Rhodesia`s capital city, Salisbury. Meikles hotel was officially opened on November 15, 1915, on the site which now houses ZB Life Towers, along Jason Moyo avenue in Harare and currently has a capacity of over 535 bedrooms. Meikles hotel holds the honour of being the first Zimbabwean hotel to attain the coveted 5-star rating, a feat it achieved in August 1983. Hotel grading was introduced in Zimbabwe in 1968, and the first results were announced in 1969. At the time, no local hotels received 4-stars, however the Ambassador Hotel, Jameson Hotel and Park Lane Hotel (now the GMB Headquarters) received 3 stars each. Interes

Covid-19 USD civil service allowances: Another money printing dalliance?

Government is the country`s largest employer, and by implication influences the spending patterns of large swathes of consumers. Establishing the exact number of civil servants under its employ is an imprecise endeavour. In an interview in August 2019, finance minister Mthuli Ncube noted that the total government payroll was about 400,000 individuals a month. Separately, some estimates put the total number of civil servants excluding those in the security forces at 250,000. Meanwhile, a 2019, Labour Force survey by ZimStat, reveals that some 249,000 people, representing 2% of the population, receive a monthly pension or some social security funds. A conservative estimate would thus arrive at a monthly amount of at least US$37.8 million, that government will be paying its workers, as part of the recently announced COVID-19 allowances, running until August 2020.  Converted at the ruling interbank rate of 57, this translates